Wednesday, July 20, 2011

Abuse of Discretion

If your like most parents, chances are you've taken your teenage kids to a movie theater, dropped them off to watch a movie with some friends in the early evening, and come back to pick them up later.

Imagine your reaction if, at the time of your return, they weren't at the designated pick-up spot? No problem; these days, most teenagers have cell phones, so you call them up to let them know you're there -- only problem? No answer. You get out of the car and start looking - and your kids are nowhere to be found.

If you're like me, panic begins to set in - until someone flags you down and tells you your kid was arrested for a curfew violation. That doesn't make sense - you know all about the curfew - you're there fully 10 minutes ahead of time - and you also know teenagers are allowed leeway to get from the theater to their parents' waiting cars. Heck, the curfew law makes a specific stipulation for that purpose.

Nope, still arrested.

That's not fiction. It's reality. It happened in Oklahoma City just last week, on Friday, July 15th, with the full story appearing in "The Oklahoman". Please, please read it.

To make matters worse, as the story notes, these teenagers were detained until 6AM the following morning for having done absolutely nothing wrong. And that's the other half of the story that just turns my outrage into full boil.

I read this story with incredulity, because I thought surely there was something that would emerge that would justify the arresting officer's actions. Surely there was an "x factor," a rude comment, an altercation, something that would justify an otherwise pointless, frightening incarceration for kids doing nothing more than watching a movie.

But there wasn't. No aggravating circumstance.

Just an out-of-control police officer abusing their discretion.

We hear varying degrees of stories like these, but rarely does one hit so close to home. I'm not one of these parents, but I just as easily could have been. I've got two teenage kids, and they enjoy movies as much as anyone else. What if that had been my son or daughter walking out of the theater while I pulled the car around? I would have been absolutely infuriated. I'd love to say I'd been the calm voice of reason, but I can't. If it were my kids, I would have been outraged.

Police have a tough job. They serve the public in ways we'll never imagine, standing in harm's way day after day. It's hard for me to be critical of police. But, in this case, there's hardly any way not to be outraged. Police, like any other people, make mistakes. But this isn't just a mistake. It is an abuse of discretion and authority that has turned perfectly innocent kids into criminals. It's almost cliche to say it, but their rights were certainly violated.

Here's hoping someone in the OKC police is held accountable.

More broadly, let's hope this never happens to anyone else.

Like me.

Or you.